PDA

View Full Version : The quickdraw that did my head in! A warning.


shanja
05-16-2007, 12:36 PM
Yesterday Kyung Ah, Karen, Eric and I hit up the wall at Asan near Cheonan. A really nice outdoor wall with heaps of that woogly exposure feeling to it, and a few easier routes too. After Eric warmed up on a far left route (where it's easier) it was my turn to lead. I jumped on feeling pretty chilled and happy, but what happened a few clips later was to really mess-up my focus and confidence for the rest of the day. A bizarre "accident".
Climbing above my last bolt to where I could just about reach the next, I heard a "bang" sort of snap sound. I looked down to see a carabiner still attached to the bolt....BUT NO QUICKDRAW. I was about 12m up I guess and on a prety cruisey route, though overhung. My last bolt (now no longer in connection with rope) was about 4 feet below and the last connected bolt a further 5 feet below that. It took a minute to think of what "had happened". It appeared that the dogbone (nylon runner sling) on my draw had snapped under the mere weight of the draw being tugged upwards as I went past! I knew they were oldish (bought in 2000), but to think that they could snap so easily made me extremely disconcerted about the potenial fall I might get...I had no confidence in them to lower off, nor to catch my fall, or even rest on. With a very attentive Eric belaying I downclimbed to the last bolt and re-clipped the rope through the bolt end crab (biner). Then down climbed to the next and did likewise again. Back on the deck we examined the failed dogbone. It hadn't broken. It wasn't torn. The crab was fine too. What in Petes name had happened???:confused8 How had a bolt end crab become estranged from it's dogbone without being subjected to a fall, a rest or anything? I know that I'd clipped it properly.:confused8
WELL HERE"S THE DEAL: After a little experimenting I found a tightish rope on an overhanging route actually could cause the draw to be lifted and the dogbone to be pulled up the gate and even to open the gate when the bolt end biner could not rotate further. I'll attach some pics to show this later. THe point is that although this was a freak happening, and I was actually able to make a bomber safe retreat (though my mind was never ble to accept my safety the rest of the day)...it can happen. So if you are climbing on those "safe as" sport walls, you still need to be careful. As you climb keep an eye on your draws and biners. Make sure they aren't being flipped, twisted or jerked into poor loading angles by rope drag or anything. Longer dogbones might have helped here too, but I'm not sure. Oh, and also if you are feeling woogly about the age/ condition of your gear it's probably time to retire it.
The Koreans who were there were really kind and supportive of us and we also met some really nice new climber friends. Cool.

Fainthearted Wack
05-16-2007, 05:32 PM
thats pretty scary. I was actually wondering about that situation happening myself, as it seems that my new quick draws are easy to unfasten.:(

ricardo
05-16-2007, 07:47 PM
wow jake!!:eek8:
glad you were able to keep it together on the retreat! i can only imagine how gripped i'd get.

so, i always understood that the bolt-biner of the draw should be loose while the rope-biner should be bound (either built into the dogbone or externally with a 'rubber band'). someone mentioned to me recently that they needed to bind the loose end of their new draws and i said they were loose on one end for a reason. with your experience though, it seems that both biners bound would have prevented this.

thoughts?

shanja
05-16-2007, 09:41 PM
I was gripped for pretty much the rest of the day...:fear: silly, becoz in fact I was safe and my gear wasn't falling apart like tissue paper as I had mistakenly first thought.
On the biner to dog-bone binding issue...I'm sure smarter folk than I have determined good reasons why the bolt biner should be loose whilst the rope crab snug. I guess the rope end biner usually is the one which catches falls, and so it's more in danger of cross-loading etc. Like I said, this incident was highly improbable, and rather uncommon in reality. But sharing "accident/ incident" beta is one way to help prevent them recurring. That is why I try and read the annual reports on "Accidents in North American Climbing" etc and encourage others to do so. I'd love to hear others views on this etc, and thanks for those of you who already have.

skinsk
05-17-2007, 09:09 AM
Miguel does a great demo on how backclipping can lead to the rope unclipping. Ask him if you see him before he leaves!

If you can recreate or find something similar diagrammed (online?), I'd be curious, esp regarding angle and the type of biner. Was the biner hanging correctly on the bolt-end?

I've seen people tape their loose ends. . . maybe those who have been thru similar? In any case, I've had gear pull, and it's freaky to look down and realize you have no pro, but in your case, not quite knowing why, or thinking a draw snapped!

When I read your title I thought a draw hit you on the head. . . and I was like, "Jake without a helmet?!"

avenue
05-17-2007, 12:44 PM
I'm really happy you're ok and were able to kinda figure out what happened. wouldn't want to lose Jake!